Which insurance agents does AI name in Sarasota?
Who ChatGPT and Gemini actually recommend when someone in Sarasota, FL asks for the best insurance agency.
What AI weighs for insurance in Sarasota
AI assistants emphasize reviews, licensing, responsiveness, and specialties when recommending insurance agencies in Sarasota, FL.
Summarised by the assistants from their own answers in this run.
How we measured this
We asked ChatGPT and Gemini the 5 buyer-intent questions people use to find insurance in Sarasota (10 answers in all), then counted which businesses each one named. Last run November 19.
Rankings reflect AI output, not endorsements, and shift as the models update. Nobody pays to appear here.
You may reuse this data with attribution to MentionedOn and a link to mentioned-on.com/top/insurance-agents/sarasota-fl. Up to 25 businesses, as of the last run date above.
Named by AI in Sarasota
Don't see your business? →- =13 tiednamed 2 of 10 each
- Sarasota Insurance Associates
Embed this result
The badge shows the count from the November 2026 run and updates when this board is rerun.
<a href="https://mentioned-on.com/top/insurance-agents/sarasota-fl" target="_blank" rel="noopener"> <img src="https://mentioned-on.com/api/public/leaderboard/badge?vertical=insurance-agents&city=sarasota-fl&business=sarasota-insurance-associates" alt="Sarasota Insurance Associates: named by AI in 2 of 10 answers, Insurance Agents in Sarasota, FL, last run November 2026, MentionedOn" width="360" height="104" loading="lazy" /> </a>
- Sarasota Insurance Agency
Embed this result
The badge shows the count from the November 2026 run and updates when this board is rerun.
<a href="https://mentioned-on.com/top/insurance-agents/sarasota-fl" target="_blank" rel="noopener"> <img src="https://mentioned-on.com/api/public/leaderboard/badge?vertical=insurance-agents&city=sarasota-fl&business=sarasota-insurance-agency" alt="Sarasota Insurance Agency: named by AI in 2 of 10 answers, Insurance Agents in Sarasota, FL, last run November 2026, MentionedOn" width="360" height="104" loading="lazy" /> </a>
- The Insurance Store
Embed this result
The badge shows the count from the November 2026 run and updates when this board is rerun.
<a href="https://mentioned-on.com/top/insurance-agents/sarasota-fl" target="_blank" rel="noopener"> <img src="https://mentioned-on.com/api/public/leaderboard/badge?vertical=insurance-agents&city=sarasota-fl&business=the-insurance-store" alt="The Insurance Store: named by AI in 2 of 10 answers, Insurance Agents in Sarasota, FL, last run November 2026, MentionedOn" width="360" height="104" loading="lazy" /> </a>
- Sarasota Insurance Associates
- =47 tiednamed 1 of 10 each
- Sarasota Insurance Enterprises
Embed this result
The badge shows the count from the November 2026 run and updates when this board is rerun.
<a href="https://mentioned-on.com/top/insurance-agents/sarasota-fl" target="_blank" rel="noopener"> <img src="https://mentioned-on.com/api/public/leaderboard/badge?vertical=insurance-agents&city=sarasota-fl&business=sarasota-insurance-enterprises" alt="Sarasota Insurance Enterprises: named by AI in 1 of 10 answers, Insurance Agents in Sarasota, FL, last run November 2026, MentionedOn" width="360" height="104" loading="lazy" /> </a>
- Allstate Agent John G. Hutton
Embed this result
The badge shows the count from the November 2026 run and updates when this board is rerun.
<a href="https://mentioned-on.com/top/insurance-agents/sarasota-fl" target="_blank" rel="noopener"> <img src="https://mentioned-on.com/api/public/leaderboard/badge?vertical=insurance-agents&city=sarasota-fl&business=allstate-agent-john-g-hutton" alt="Allstate Agent John G. Hutton: named by AI in 1 of 10 answers, Insurance Agents in Sarasota, FL, last run November 2026, MentionedOn" width="360" height="104" loading="lazy" /> </a>
- State Farm - John D. McCarthy
Embed this result
The badge shows the count from the November 2026 run and updates when this board is rerun.
<a href="https://mentioned-on.com/top/insurance-agents/sarasota-fl" target="_blank" rel="noopener"> <img src="https://mentioned-on.com/api/public/leaderboard/badge?vertical=insurance-agents&city=sarasota-fl&business=state-farm-john-d-mccarthy" alt="State Farm - John D. McCarthy: named by AI in 1 of 10 answers, Insurance Agents in Sarasota, FL, last run November 2026, MentionedOn" width="360" height="104" loading="lazy" /> </a>
- Allstate - Chris M. McCarthy
Embed this result
The badge shows the count from the November 2026 run and updates when this board is rerun.
<a href="https://mentioned-on.com/top/insurance-agents/sarasota-fl" target="_blank" rel="noopener"> <img src="https://mentioned-on.com/api/public/leaderboard/badge?vertical=insurance-agents&city=sarasota-fl&business=allstate-chris-m-mccarthy" alt="Allstate - Chris M. McCarthy: named by AI in 1 of 10 answers, Insurance Agents in Sarasota, FL, last run November 2026, MentionedOn" width="360" height="104" loading="lazy" /> </a>
- State Farm Agent Chris Dyer
Embed this result
The badge shows the count from the November 2026 run and updates when this board is rerun.
<a href="https://mentioned-on.com/top/insurance-agents/sarasota-fl" target="_blank" rel="noopener"> <img src="https://mentioned-on.com/api/public/leaderboard/badge?vertical=insurance-agents&city=sarasota-fl&business=state-farm-agent-chris-dyer" alt="State Farm Agent Chris Dyer: named by AI in 1 of 10 answers, Insurance Agents in Sarasota, FL, last run November 2026, MentionedOn" width="360" height="104" loading="lazy" /> </a>
- State Farm - Mike O'Connor
Embed this result
The badge shows the count from the November 2026 run and updates when this board is rerun.
<a href="https://mentioned-on.com/top/insurance-agents/sarasota-fl" target="_blank" rel="noopener"> <img src="https://mentioned-on.com/api/public/leaderboard/badge?vertical=insurance-agents&city=sarasota-fl&business=state-farm-mike-o-connor" alt="State Farm - Mike O'Connor: named by AI in 1 of 10 answers, Insurance Agents in Sarasota, FL, last run November 2026, MentionedOn" width="360" height="104" loading="lazy" /> </a>
- State Farm - Brian McNulty
Embed this result
The badge shows the count from the November 2026 run and updates when this board is rerun.
<a href="https://mentioned-on.com/top/insurance-agents/sarasota-fl" target="_blank" rel="noopener"> <img src="https://mentioned-on.com/api/public/leaderboard/badge?vertical=insurance-agents&city=sarasota-fl&business=state-farm-brian-mcnulty" alt="State Farm - Brian McNulty: named by AI in 1 of 10 answers, Insurance Agents in Sarasota, FL, last run November 2026, MentionedOn" width="360" height="104" loading="lazy" /> </a>
- Sarasota Insurance Enterprises
Listed above? Track whether you stay named. Positions here are not for sale and change as the models update.
Ask an assistant yourself
One of the 5 buyer questions this board is built from, exactly as the links below send it. Open it in an assistant and read the answer yourself.
Best insurance agent in Sarasota, FL?
Answers vary from run to run, so asking twice can give different results.
Not on the list? Check your own business.
Track your insurance agency in Sarasota with a 7-day trial: your AI visibility, the competitors named in these answers, and suggested next steps. The trial covers ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity, Grok and Copilot: all six when it starts and in the Monday sweep, with daily checks on ChatGPT and Gemini.
Free, with no signup or card. Results in about 30 seconds.
Check my business free. Free, with no signup or card. Results in about 30 seconds.
This public board covers ChatGPT and Gemini. One scan adds Claude, Perplexity, Grok and Copilot.
Or see how businesses get recommended by AI.
Top insurance in other cities
Other trades in Sarasota
Questions about this leaderboard
How are these insurance agents ranked?+
We ask ChatGPT and Gemini the questions customers in Sarasota, FL actually use, then count which businesses each one names. It's not an ad, no one pays to appear. A scan of your own business is wider: it checks ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity, Grok and Copilot, and Local and Growth also check Google AI Overviews and AI Mode.
How do I get my insurance agency listed?+
Get recommended by the assistants themselves: strengthen your Google Business Profile, reviews, and presence in the local sources AI draws on. Start a 7-day trial to see where you stand, with suggested next steps. $0 today, then $99/month. Card required. Cancel anytime.
How often is this updated?+
We refresh these leaderboards regularly as the models and the sources they cite change, so the rankings reflect current AI answers.