Top insurance agents in Columbus
Who 4 AI assistants actually recommend when someone in Columbus, OH asks for the best insurance agency.
“AI assistants emphasize reviews, licensing, responsiveness, and specialties when recommending insurance agencies in Columbus, OH.”, what AI weighs for insurance here
Measured from 5 buyer questions × 4 assistants · updated July 10
- 1GEICOnamed 3×
- 2Brian at Grimone Ledbetternamed 2×
- 3Farmers Insurance - The Mike McGowan Agencynamed 1×
- 4Farmers Insurance - John D. Huber Agencynamed 1×
- 5State Farm - John W. McGowan Agencynamed 1×
- 6Hugh W. McCauley Insurance Agencynamed 1×
- 7Allstate - The Kelsey Dyer Agencynamed 1×
- 8State Farm - The Dan Dyer Agencynamed 1×
- 9The O'Connor Insurance Groupnamed 1×
- 10W.E. Davis Insurance Agencynamed 1×
Not on the list? That's fixable.
Run a free scan for your insurance agency in Columbus, your AI visibility score, the competitors winning these answers, and the plan to get named.
Or see how businesses get recommended by AI.
Top insurance in other cities
Other trades in Columbus
Questions about this leaderboard
How are these insurance agents ranked?+
We ask 4 AI assistants the questions customers in Columbus, OH actually use, then count which businesses each one names. It's not an ad, no one pays to appear. Your free scorecard checks four chat assistants; paid monitoring adds Google's two AI search surfaces.
How do I get my insurance agency listed?+
Get recommended by the assistants themselves: strengthen your Google Business Profile, reviews, and presence in the local sources AI draws on. Run a free scan to see where you stand and a prioritized plan.
How often is this updated?+
We refresh these leaderboards regularly as the models and the sources they cite change, so the rankings reflect current AI answers.
How this is measured: we ask 4 AI assistants the buyer-intent questions for insurance in Columbus, then count which businesses each one names. Rankings reflect AI output, not endorsements, and shift as the models update.